Charles Thomas Jackson, “The Head Behind the Hands.” Applying Science to Implement Discovery in Early Nineteenth Century America. By Richard J. Wolfe, M.L.S., and Richard Patterson, M.D., Novato, California, Jeremy Norman & Co., 2007. Pages: 417. Price: $35.00.

This is the third book by Richard J. Wolfe, formerly Curator of Rare Books at the Harvard Medical Library, that directly or indirectly seeks to answer the age-old question, “Who was the discoverer of surgical anesthesia?” Nearly all the other screeds about this question use the same unsupported tales and myths about Long, Wells, Morton, Jackson and others: they merely copy anecdotal history from each other (for example the story that Jackson went bananas when he saw the Morton Monument). Wolfe and colleagues have dug deeply into primary sources hidden in dusty niches in obscure libraries. I bet they sneezed a lot.

In his first book, I Awaken to Glory , Wolfe is the editor of a series of well-documented essays reminding us powerfully of Horace Wells’s important role. The second book, Tarnished Idol , of which Wolfe is the sole author, convinces us that William T.G. Morton was a criminal before he became a dentist and developed the practical use of ether for general anesthesia. He defrauded and cheated his business associates in cities all over the then-known United States.

The purpose of this new book is to persuade us that Charles Thomas Jackson, who gave Morton a little background information about ether and spent the rest of his life claiming priority for the Great Invention, was not as crazy as has been previously alleged. The critical incident reported in this book concerns the accidental meeting in Fall 1832 of Jackson and Samuel Morse on the boat Sully  as it crossed the Atlantic Ocean from Europe to America. Morse, a successful artist, had become interested in the possibility of developing an electric telegraph. He and passengers on the Sully , including Jackson, chatted about the possibility of sending messages through wires. Jackson later claimed he had given Morse the whole idea. The meat of this book consists of sworn depositions given by Jackson in the course of complicated lawsuits brought by others claiming they, and not Morse, were responsible for key elements of the electric telegraph.

What does this have to do with the invention of anesthesia? Not too much except that, if this book convinces you that Jackson was the “brain” behind others’ inventions, you will believe he should get credit for what happened in the Ether Dome at 10:16 am on October 16, 1846.

Why am I not convinced after reading this book? There is simply too much evidence to suggest that Jackson was an idle lay-about from a well-off family. He may well have had the ideas, but so might many others.

If you walk to the top of the hill that dominates the Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge, Massachusetts, you will come across a headstone that reads as follows: “Charles Thomas Jackson MD: June 21 1805– August 28 1880. Thy godlike crime was to be kind, to render with thy precepts less the sum of human wretchedness and strengthen man with his own mind.”

Don’t you find it unusual to read a defense against an unspecified accusation on a headstone? Paranoia, perhaps?

Then drive to Plymouth where the Pilgrims set up shop in December 1620. Go to the headquarters of the Society of Mayflower Descendants on North Street. The courteous guide will show you the room where Jackson’s sister, Lidian, married Ralph Waldo Emerson. In the corner of that room you will see a rocking chair in dark lacquer. Firmly attached to the back is a brass plaque that reads as follows: “In This Chair Dr. Charles Jackson Discovered Etherization, February 1842”

What A surprise! I always thought that Crawford Long gave ether to James Venable on March 30, 1842.

Reading biographies of historical figures is often like eating All-Bran with skim milk – tasteless but efficient. However, some biographies, including this book, resemble the lush pleasures of Frosted Flakes in full cream milk. Take this sentence from the book’s opening chapter: “Charles Thomas Jackson … emerges from the same scrutiny shorn of his black-sheep coat and divested of the ugly warts of untruth and misconception that have disfigured his character …”

This semibiography can best be understood by asking four questions.

Is it a meticulous piece of historical research that unearths many documents previously interred in archives and libraries? Yes.

Does it support the grandiose statement on its cover, “Applying Science to Implement Discovery and Invention in Early Nineteenth Century America?” No.

Does it add to our understanding of Jackson’s role in the introduction of ether as a general anesthetic? No.

Is it easy reading? No.

Jackson’s life may be summarized by a modification of the aphorism, “Those who can, do. Those who cannot, teach (and lie).” This statement is not just my opinion. Edward Wangenknecht, a recent biographer of Emerson, quoting from one of that luminary’s journals, wrote, “… that he (Emerson) had learned nothing of value from his contacts with Jackson.”

Jackson could best be described by the Yiddish word “luftmensch” or “air-person”– an imaginative dreamer who never actually achieves anything useful. In Jackson’s case, it could be a person who never lifted a finger except to start petitions retrospectively, laying claim to others’ laborious inventions.

I suspect that Wolfe and Patterson, both sincere and honorable historians, believe the same; but in this book they are also having a little fun with us. They enjoy adding an incendiary log to the fire of the Great Anesthesia Question (enshrined forever in the Wood Library’s T-shirts): “Who Was First?

(Formerly) Harvard Medical School, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts.